so there have been many wars, historically over resources, that bit was easy to understand, no ability to communicate or trade left people desperate
then of course people asked why it is that some people continually are running out of resources, so along came joseph in his natty threads and his dream prophecy, so granaries became popular and small wars could be avoided, so societies became larger
but even after giving egypt the life saving concept of saving, josephs descendants were evicted from egypt, mostly due to jealousy, so then came moses with his commandments, and medium sized wars were avoided
then came world war
which i am afraid that if i tried to deconstruct the specific reasons for it, this entire forum would be deleted like it was last time i dared mention it, so you'll have to guess that part or i would not be able to continue talking...
though in general terms it was a violation of all 10 commandments
now we have 'terrorism' which i am also scared to talk about or somebody may delete the forum again
so instead of offending with truth, i'll use metaphor and a leading argument to get the readers and the hackers to realise for themselves
lets talk about syria what is the given excuse for that one?
lavender orchid
Posts : 858 Join date : 2010-07-16
Subject: Re: why o why war? Wed Feb 27, 2013 3:32 pm
ahh, in other words, what have we been able to learn from it so far????
the stories were no longer passed on by word of mouth.
\!! !!...
https://youtu.be/d_dx4UE-Gn4
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: why o why war? Wed Feb 27, 2013 7:18 pm
http://www.icpe.org/statement.html
Spoiler:
sometimes men are good for other stuff too besides war. sometimes.
lavender orchid
Posts : 858 Join date : 2010-07-16
Subject: Re: why o why war? Thu Feb 28, 2013 3:42 am
Last edited by lavender orchid on Thu Feb 28, 2013 5:23 am; edited 1 time in total
Jonathan Ainsley Bain :SPOCK: - Ship's physicist.
Posts : 257 Join date : 2013-02-14
Subject: Re: why o why war? Thu Feb 28, 2013 4:57 am
well war is diminishing somewhat, so 'we' seem to have learnt some things, however many people suffer from the illusion that religion was somehow to blame for war, when the 10 commandments actually prevent war, so perhaps its the 2nd commandment that needs to be learnt most deeply still, that is there is a large difference between religion and idolatry many people profess religion while not living it and many have learnt some of the 10 commandments without acknowledging that the origin of these ethics are indeed religious
however the commandments violated most in my immediate social milieu would be the last 3 :
jealousy, lies, and theft
of course poverty is the result of infidelity as unwanted children from an unloved spouse are tossed aside
you cannot really separate the 10 commandments from each other as violations to one cause violations to another
for instance, the bible is lacking as regards astronomy so people with guilt use this as a 'reason' to reject it (so that they can temporarily avoid guilt) then the karmic wave catches up to them and they in turn 'blame religion'
its tough raising kids, yes?
well its much tougher trying to teach adults with ingrained child-like mentality more so when they have a veneer of success inherited
Jonathan Ainsley Bain :SPOCK: - Ship's physicist.
Posts : 257 Join date : 2013-02-14
Subject: Re: why o why war? Thu Feb 28, 2013 5:02 am
this is why i feel that my book flight light and spin
was written to bridge the gap between modern cosmology and biblical ethics but i am trying to understand why i am having such trouble in getting it 'out there'
i must be violating a commandment in my own life somewhere even if its not one of the 10,
perhaps i really do need a great woman to assist me and its my own vanity that leads me to believe i can do it without her
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: why o why war? Sat Mar 02, 2013 12:31 am
each of us has got to find the internal ARTillery of the Soul and the terrorist inside of our own being sometimes you have seen mine
Spoiler:
Guest Guest
Subject: Re: why o why war? Sat Mar 02, 2013 1:32 pm
Spoiler:
molitva
Posts : 20 Join date : 2013-04-30 Location : location
"biblical ethics" had 13 centuries to eradicate war in Europe, and it utterly failed.
Instead, Christianity was used as an excuse by Charlemagne to slaughter whole villages of scandinavians. Christianity was used as as excuse to wage the 6 (or 7) wars of aggression into the middle east, roughly referred to as The Crusades. Christianity was used as the excuse for the 30 years war in Germany following the Protestant Reformation. Even late 20th-century northern Ireland was incapable of making any kind of peace from the Bible.
Second -- what in the world is biblical ethics? "Do not work your oxen , nor your lady-servant on the Sabbath. " (>?)
Is that ethics? No. Ethics is David Hume's is-ought, and distinctions between normative language and descriptive language.
lavender orchid
Posts : 858 Join date : 2010-07-16
Subject: Re: why o why war? Wed May 01, 2013 11:55 am
see also http://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007%2FBFb0019928#page-1
Mayflow Starfleet Commander
Posts : 341 Join date : 2009-05-20
Subject: Re: why o why war? Fri May 03, 2013 6:51 pm
War comes from negative feelings of need and of want. Destroy and replant such feelings and thoughts and ideas with feelings of non-possessive love, and war has no place for us anymore.
Jonathan Ainsley Bain :SPOCK: - Ship's physicist.
Posts : 257 Join date : 2013-02-14
Subject: Re: why o why war? Sat May 04, 2013 6:22 am
Anyone who thinks that Christianity is a cause of war, must come and live in the third world for a few generations; and not hidden behind their mostly-white nationalist apartheid wall.
That western way of life is christian, and it is only christian countries that have it.
European pagans practiced all manner of executions, from war to genocide. Any person can pick up any flag and wage war under it.
The central cause of war is that people breed faster than the environment can sustain. A literate society knows better what can sustain it; than an illiterate one. Christianity is the most mature form of literacy as it heralds the great scientist instead of crucifying him.
The only alternative that the west has to offer, is dawkins and his "fcuk everybody as often as possible" ideology. This is the same practiced by heathens all over the world in many guises.
When i was a kid, my folks bought me a cage with two mice in it. Within no time there were 50 mice, and new litters every day. These are very cute white friendly mice normally. The mice were sent to the snake park before K-factor kicked in.
k-factor is simply that if you do not have enough space - then you kill for it. But living behind the great christian army that was victorious over the axis whoremongers - you lot have not begun to even see what violence is - let alone experienced it first hand. But you will soon.
Sodomy itself is a symptom of the beginnings of population density and stress as a result - where women reject the child for lack of love - it all got used on the father - now the man is the wetnurse to stop that infernal howling - now the boy child acquires unnatural desires - and the girl child overpowering desire - which exacerbates the situation. One cannot convince the sodomite that rape is wrong.
Fidelity and Celibacy are the only solutions. Such will power is something that only few can manage. The flags of the victors carry the message of survival - The crucifix trumps all even according to the most cynical survivor. Even neo-darwinists have to face the fact that christianity is the best survivor.
Truth is suffering. Once you realize that, the suffering ends.
Selah
molitva
Posts : 20 Join date : 2013-04-30 Location : location
Subject: Re: why o why war? Fri Jun 21, 2013 8:53 am
Thanks for this, Bain. This is actually very good and I agree pretty much with all of it.
I have to say, I am glad I logged back in here. I've been beating around the Philosophy Now! forum, and it is very depressing.
I feel refreshed here.
Thanks.
lavender orchid
Posts : 858 Join date : 2010-07-16
Subject: Re: why o why war? Fri Jun 21, 2013 4:12 pm